Neutral eyeshadow is one of those things in life that are here to stay! Fashions come and go, but neutrals are timeless and a neutral eyeshadow look is one you simply can’t go wrong with.
We’ve put together the very best neutral eyeshadow palettes of all time! With these eyeshadow palettes, you can create any look, from cut-crease to smokey and everyday to party.
We’ve included and reviewed eyeshadow palettes for all budgets, needs and of all eyeshadow finishes. From designer palettes to drugstore ones, we’ve got you covered!
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases on Amazon and other affiliate programs. This means on some purchases, I make a commission. It doesn’t mean you spend more, it simply allows me to keep this blog going!
Is any eyeshadow palette review ever complete without a Natasha Denona palette? We don’t think so! Starting off these neutral eyeshadow palettes, we have the beautiful Natasha Denona Glam Eyeshadow Palette!
Glam indeed, this palette is perfection in every way and a bestseller too. With 15 cool and neutral shades, it’s the ideal palette to create a neutral eye look. A cute and useful add-on to the glam palette is that the shades are labelled to help you create the perfect look.
You don’t need to be a pro at applying eyeshadow, the palette tells you exactly what to do with names like ‘outer eye lid’ and ‘crease’. It features mostly metallic and shimmer shades, but it has enough mattes to create a matte look too.
Like all Natasha Denona makeup, the Glam eyeshadow palette has amazingly soft and easy-to-use shades. Buttery to use, with very little fallout this eyeshadow palette will not fail you!
Natasha Denona Glam Eyeshadow Palette is cruelty-free.
The Tarte Tartelette In Bloom Clay Eyeshadow Palette is a favourite by many. Just looking at the palette you can understand why. It has all the neutral shades you would need for a smokey eye look or an everyday simple neutral eyeshadow look.
If you love your neutrals, you will love this palette, it’s simple, has lovely shades and has amazing quality!
All of the shades in the palettes are really useful. All too often we use only a few shades in a palette, leaving some completely untouched. Well, that’s not the case here. Each and every shade is beautiful and useful!
The palette is long-wearing and made with Amazonian clay to prevent smudging and creasing. It’s also dermatologist and pathologist tested. Tarte Tartelette In Bloom Clay Eyeshadow Palette is cruelty-free.
When it comes to affordability versus quality, NYX makeup is all the way up there! Their makeup is top quality, while they are still relatively affordable.
NYX Ultimate Shadow Palettes come in a variety of colour combinations, ranging from fabulous bright colours, to calm neutrals. Yep, we’re going to focus on the neutrals, after all, this is all about neutral eyeshadow palettes!
NYX Professional Makeup Ultimate Shadow Palette in Warm Neutrals comes with 16 neutral shades. They are warm-toned, as the name suggests, so while they would work with all skin tones, this palette would look best on warm skin tones.
The palette comes with a variety of shade finishes, from matte to shimmer and metallic. You can wear this palette for an everyday basic look, or you can go all out with a smokey eye-shimmery look!
Small enough to fit in your handbag, yet big enough to give you the full eyeshadow package! NYX Professional Makeup Ultimate Shadow Palette is cruelty-free.
The Too Faced Natural Eyes Neutral Eyeshadow Palette is a no-frills, simple eyeshadow palette. If you are wondering why such a simple palette has made it onto this post on the best neutral eyeshadow palettes, let me explain!
For many, less is more. An eyeshadow palette that features loads of shades is great, but for many people, it’s like overstimulation. They simply get overwhelmed by it and don’t know which shade to use and when.
That’s where simple eyeshadows like the Natural Eyes Neutral Eyeshadow Palette come in! It’s easy to use and even if you’re not a pro at eyeshadow, it will not overwhelm you. The eyeshadow palette comes with 9 neutral matte, pearl and sparkle shades featuring 6 shades of browns and 3 lighter pink and beige shades.
Cleverly thought out, the base shades have oversized pans ensuring you don’t run out of the most used shades before the other ones. It’s a nice and thoughtful touch!
Enriched with coconut butter, the formulas are soft and buttery to use and apply. Like all Too Faced makeup, this eyeshadow palette features only highly pigmented shades that produce very little fallout. My only criticism of the palette is the provocative names they’ve given to the shades.
This palette would be perfect for beginners, but honestly, I would think twice before giving my teenage daughter an eyeshadow palette featuring names like ‘hooker’ and the like. The teenage years are shakey enough without added challenges!
Aside from that, it’s really a fab palette, it has good quality shades that are beautiful too! Too Faced Natural Eyes Neutral Eyeshadow Palette is cruelty-free.
Are you fed up with the trillions of products that ColourPop brings out?! If that’s a yes, bear with us for a moment because this is a palette not worth passing on!
It’s the ultimate neutral eyeshadow palette! Ideal for smokey looks as well as all other ones, the ColourPop Bare Necessities is jam-packed with colours and options!
When it comes to ColourPop eyeshadow palettes, it’s rather hard to decide what to love more- the prices, creative shades and palettes or the quality. For me, it’s all of it! Their shades are alive, and bright and blend like a dream!
From what I hear on the grapevine, there’s a new 30-pan palette on the way called Smoke N’ Roses. Similar to Bare Necessities but with pinkier shades! However, if it’s neutrals you’re looking for, the Bare Necessities is the palette you need!
ColourPop Bare Necessities is cruelty-free.
Makeup Revolution is another favourite brand of ours! Why? It’s really simple, they have beautiful, original makeup with amazing quality and they are constantly bringing out new collections. And of course, they are super-affordable too! You get the full package with them so what’s not to love?!
Makeup Revolution Forever Flawless Dynamic Eye Shadow Palette is a mini palette that comes in 8 different shade variations, all based on the full-sized Forever Flawless Palette. The palette we’re including is naturally the neutral palette- Serenity!
Featuring 8 stunning neutral shades with matte, shimmer and foil finishes. It’s more of a party palette, but there are enough shades to create an everyday look too.
Makeup Revolution Forever Flawless Dynamic Eye Shadow Palette is vegan and cruelty-free.
Urban Decay Naked Eyeshadow Palettes are a fave by many, not just for the colours, but also because of the quality! But yes, the colours do play a factor too, just look at them and it’s not hard to see why!
The Naked3 palette features 12 dazzling nude shades in all warm shades of pink and brown. It has a combination of matte, shimmer and metallic finishes giving you the option of many different looks. From parties to every day, this palette has something for everyone!
All of the Naked palettes, including this one, feature velvety formulas with the intense colour payoff and staying power that we all look for in an eyeshadow palette.
As a bonus, the palette also comes with a double-ended eyeshadow brush because why not make the palette even better than it already is? Urban Decay recently released a mini version of their classic Naked3 Palette, read the full review here.
Urban Decay Cosmetics Naked3 Eyeshadow Palette is cruelty-free.
For those who don’t stray from their neutrals, we have the beautiful Smashbox Cover Shot Eyeshadow Palette in Minimalist.
The Cover Shot Eyeshadow Palette comes in a variety of colour options, but we think the Minimalist palette is the most appropriate- you can’t really get more neutral than this palette!
Smashbox Cover Shot Eyeshadow Palette comes in 8 shades, including 2 base shades that have bigger pans than the other 6. It’s a nice touch since we all tend to use the base shades the most especially because it goes on the whole eyelid.
Smashbox describes the Minimalist palette as effortlessly versatile neutrals, and we couldn’t agree more! It’s the perfect palette for a no-makeup makeup look. The shades are ideal for giving your eyes a smooth look and natural contour, perfect for a wedding!
The Maybelline Nudes of New York Eyeshadow Palette is unique in the sense that it is a highly affordable palette that comes with all the neutral shades you could dream of.
From pinks to golds and mattes to shimmers, it has it all. And it’s loved by many for that exact reason! It’s designed to flatter all skin tones with its 16 new shades and its warm tones are perfect for spring and summer.
The shades are vibrant and will never look dull or dreary as many cheaper palettes tend to look. With creamy formulas, the eyeshadows are easy to apply and are highly pigmented too.
Use it for glam or for every day, this eyeshadow palette has a shade for every occasion!
Morphe 18T Truth or Bare Artistry Palette has all the shades for a neutral eye look, from pinks to browns as well as beiges and shimmers. The palette comes with fab 18 shades in matte, shimmer and metallic finishes.
While this is a neutral palette, what’s extra nice about it is that it has a few purple shades too, giving it a splash of colour. Sometimes you want a little colour and the Morphe 18T Truth or Bare Artistry Palette is ideal for that!
We simply couldn’t pass on this palette because just look how gorgeous it is! The shade range is amazing and the shadows are creamy and easy to apply without much fallout.
Like with all eyeshadows, if you want it to stay in place I recommend using an eyeshadow primer. Morphe 18T Truth or Bare Artistry Palette is cruelty-free.
Eyeshadow Application Tips
Have you ever wondered why your eyeshadow tends to look bland and not like the images you see on Instagram or Pinterest? Yep, we’ve all been there and done that!
There is an art to getting your eyeshadow right, and it’s not always about skill. Sometimes you just need a little help and here we’re going to share with you the tricks to getting beautiful eyeshadow EVERY TIME!
1. Use an eyeshadow primer
An eyeshadow primer will not only help your eyeshadow stay on for longer, but it also helps eyeshadow apply better. It gives the eyeshadow a smoother base to apply and increases the pigmentation sticking to your eyes.
More pigmentation = better eyeshadow! Our favourite eyeshadow primers are the Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion and the MAC Prep + Prime 24-Hour Eye Base. The MAC primer is the stronger one of the 2, so if you need serious staying power, opt for MAC. It’s like glue in a bottle!
2. Always apply a base shade
Using a base shade is necessary for eyeshadow because it evens out the skin tone. It gives you a flat base on which to apply eyeshadow.
When you don’t use a base shade, your eyeshadow is much more likely to look uneven and splotchy. Most eyeshadow palettes come with a neutral base shade on which you can create any eyeshadow look.
3. Use a setting spray
Use a setting spray, but not in the traditional way that you think! Spray your eyeshadow brush before applying shimmers and metallics for an intense colour payoff.
Instead of the shadows going everywhere, as shimmers tend to do, spray some setting spray for the shimmers to stick to the brush and then your eyelids! It’s a simple eyeshadow hack that can make all the difference!
Get some more eyeshadow application tips with these 10 professional tips and tricks! If you suffer from oily eyelids, read how I apply makeup to my oily eyelids for lasting results.
My Thoughts On Neutral Palettes
We hope you’ve found the neutral eyeshadow palette that works best for you. Obviously, we won’t judge you if you had to buy all 10! We get it, neutral eyeshadow palettes really are the best and timeless too. You can never have too many of them, we’re sure you agree!
Hi, I’m Hollie, and I’m passionate about everything beauty. Over the last decade and a half, I’ve tested thousands of products to bring you the best of the best! I also love bringing you fun and creative beauty looks. Learn more.
Beauty profile – 35, dry, aging skin, focused on aging well with a healthy glow and natural makeup look ✨
- I Reviewed Fenty Beauty Pro Filt’r Concealer and Said Goodbye to My Under-Eye Creasing
- 15 Hacks For Applying Nail Polish Like A Pro
- 30 Stunning Winter Hair Color Ideas for a Killer Look
- 10 Tips on How to Apply Highlighter to Pale Skin
- 15 Easy Winter Makeup Tips for Glowing Skin
- Everything You Need to Know About MAC’s Frosted Frenzy Advent Calendar 2023
- CurrentBody Skin Radio Frequency Device Review- Does it Work?
- Eye Makeup Tips You Need To Try for Sensitive Eyes
- How To Use Body Lotion and Its Benefits For the Skin
Anastasia Beverly Hills bareMinerals Benefit Cosmetics Bobbi Brown CeraVe Chantecaille Charlotte Tilbury Clarins ColourPop Dermalogica Dior Dyson e.l.f. Cosmetics ELEMIS Estée Lauder Eucerin Fenty Beauty Fresh Giorgio Armani Hourglass IT Cosmetics L'Oreal Lancome Laura Mercier LORAC MAC Makeup Revolution Maybelline Molton Brown Morphe Nars Natasha Denona Neutrogena NYX Origins Peter Thomas Roth PÜR Cosmetics Revlon Sigma Beauty Smashbox Stila The Ordinary Too Faced Urban Decay YSL