Some people like expensive makeup and others prefer cheap makeup. I like the best of both, cheap with expensive quality! There’s nothing that gives me more satisfaction than buying items for a bargain! Especially when it comes to makeup!
If you can save big and get luxury products for less, then why not?! I get it, luxury eyeshadow palettes are luxurious and I do love luxury, but a good dupe is a delightful feeling!
I’ve gone through way too many eyeshadow palettes to bring you the best eyeshadow palettes in every colour and finish! Instead of the classic eyeshadow dupes of expensive vs. cheap, I’ve brought you the mid-range too. For each coloured palette, you will see the luxury dupe, vs the mid-range dupe, vs the cheap dupe!
Get the best eyeshadow palette dupes for luxury brands like Natasha Denona, Viseart, Pat McGrath and Charlotte Tilbury. Get ready to save big this 2024 without compromising on the formula, quality and colours!
I’ve divided the eyeshadows into their colour stories. From purples and greens to nudes and pinks, and rainbows and reds, we have you covered! I’ve compared the colours as well as the pigmentation and how easy the palettes are to blend.
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases on Amazon and other affiliate programs. This means on some purchases, I make a commission. It doesn’t mean you spend more, it simply allows me to keep this blog going!
Rainbow Eyeshadow Palette Dupes
Rainbow palettes aren’t for everyone. Mostly because we have this fear that we may never really use them to their full potential. And it’s a valid concern.
But in all scrutiny, having a rainbow palette ready on the side is like owning 5 separate palettes. Simply because you get all the colours of the rainbow in one palette! Rainbow eyeshadows are flexible, especially when they contain a nude or two.
There are those people that are all about the bright and flashy colours that rainbow palettes have to offer. The colours are fun and different and nowadays anything and everything goes!
A rainbow palette with base shades offers an abundance of eyeshadow looks waiting for you to try. And when you are out scouring the internet for “unique eyeshadow looks” or “bold eyeshadow looks”, you’ll likely have an easier time recreating these with a rainbow palette.
Viseart is a monster in the realm of professional makeup artists. Steep price tags, quality formulas, and super-pigmented shadows. Whilst I love Viseart, I’m not 100% sure about the price! If it would be the only palette I would ever buy, then I could justify it.
However, since I’m a makeup junkie and the more palettes I have in my eyeshadow collection the better, it’s time for some dupes!
A rainbow palette like the Viseart Editorial Brights SlimPro can be substituted for the James Charles Artistry Palette, and the Makeup Revolution Reloaded Monster Matte palette.
These three palettes are all ‘rainbow palettes’ and are all very similar to each other in colour. They all offer the main rainbow colours along with a few nudes to use as base shades.
While the Editorial Brights SlimPro and Monster Mattes are 100% matte-only finishes, you’ll get some extra shimmer and glitter shadows with the Morphe James Charles Palette.
There are also several other extra shades on the James Charles palette that aren’t present in the other two, like some hypnotizing black shades, and some must-have purple colours to balance out the bold primary colours.
The Monster Matte palette isn’t quite as buttery as the Editorial Brights SlimPro and it has some fallout. However, it is very easy to use and the huge price difference is definitely worth a little fallout!
The Makeup Revolution Monster Matte palette will give you an equally all-matte rainbow palette with a bigger choice of colours.
Morphe X James Charles Artistry Palette sits right in the middle of the other 2 when it comes to quality and formula.
While it may not be as luxurious and pigmented as the Viseart Brights SlimPro, it’s good quality, has lovely formulas and has more colours!
Warm Nudes & Oranges
Warm nudes oranges are one of the more universal palettes to have. They’re also one of the most commonly offered colour stories in the cosmetics industry because who doesn’t like a little sultry every once in a while?
Perfect for all seasons and most skin tones too. A touch of the orange spectrum can help you achieve peachy or sunny shadow looks.
The shades always match each other because the colours are analogous and harmonious together. These palettes are perfect for those who love a pretty nude but want to add a touch of colour.
Adding shimmers to oranges will help to create depth to your look. Warm nudes and oranges are versatile and really you can create any look you want from them, from smokey eyes to subtle and natural-looking day looks.
Based on looks alone, wouldn’t you agree that the shades found on the palettes below are basic yet versatile? Unvarying yet inclusive?
Each has 9 shades
The Natasha Denona Sunset Palette has a hefty price of over £100. It’s definitely a palette that’s well worth its price. The colours are all absolutely stunning! I can imagine myself using this palette very well:)
The colours are workable and have a thoughtful mix of shimmer, matte and satin finishes. It’s a palette that can be worn every day throughout the year and for any occasion.
I’ve included two of Huda Beauty’s Obsessions palettes because together they recreate the Sunset palette. You’ll get the same colours minus the white ones.
However, they don’t all have the same finishes. The nude and orange finishes vary on both palettes, and Huda’s formula and texture are a lot creamier. On the other hand, Natasha has some buttery textures to live for!
With that said, if you don’t mind the finish, Huda is a great alternative for 18 shadows of almost all the same colours versus 15 eyeshadows with four times the price you’ll pay for one Obsessions palette.
We’ve all come to love the budget-friendly brand ColourPop. They have new releases more frequently than you can say boo!
Every week is another great release, and when I say great, their products are just that. The formulas are A1, the colours are spot-on, and their makeup is totally Instagrammable!
If you’re looking for a palette even cheaper than Huda Beauty, the ColourPop California Love Palette is the one you need! It swatches almost identically to both the Natasha Denona and Huda palettes!
Although you will be missing out on more options for deeper hues, I think California Love offers enough shades for plenty of beautiful looks and your wallet will thank you too!
All 3 of these palettes have earned their right to be here. They are all high-quality eyeshadow palettes with beautiful colours and great colour payoff. However, if you have oily or sensitive skin, I recommend the Natasha Denona palette which is oil-free and vegan.
Neutrals & Blues
Blue eyeshadow was a highly coveted look back in the 50s, even Barbie wore them! It’s Disney’s go-to eyeshadow on almost all their iconic princess characters, as well as their sassy villains.
Blue eyeshadows are also an instant retro take on makeup. But that isn’t to say it instantly makes you look extreme. It just says you’ve been (or read) through a whole era of makeup where blue eyeshadow was the norm.
Btw, a small tip: if you have green eyes and you want them to pop- wear blue eyeshadow! Wearing blue eyeshadow when you have blue eyes will make your eyes appear less blue. Colours have a way of their own!
Neutral eyeshadows, on the other hand, came to rise thanks to Bobbi Brown in the 90s when people started to opt for calmer, more inviting makeup using neutral colours of white, black, grey, browns, and bridges. ( As a neutral-obsessed fanatic, I am eternally grateful for that!)
Mix both colour stories together and BAM! You get palettes like the Pat McGrath Mothership I, Smashbox Double Exposure 2.0, and The Tarte Winter Wonderglam eyeshadows. You get the best of both worlds.
These shades are perfectly suitable together as they fall under the split complementary colour scheme.
Many think Pat McGrath’s shadows are undupable. But with thousands of palettes released from numerous cosmetic brands, I wasn’t buying that.
Yes, the formula is really outstanding and one of the best! But if you just want to follow McGrath’s unique eyeshadow tutorials and can’t get your hands on the palette yet, Smashbox has your back.
The colours are extremely similar and the quality is very high-end. The shadows are pigmented and blend easily without a lot of fallout.
Finding a budget dupe for both the Pat McGrath Subliminal Palette and the Smashbox Double Exposure proved a little more difficult. The colour story just exudes luxury with is always harder to find with budget makeup.
However, I struck gold or more like blue when I found the Revolution Colour Focus Palette Night & Day. The main difference between the two palettes is the packaging- one is black and one is white. Oh, and the price!
The colours are almost identical with the layout being the same too. The Makeup Revolution palette has a bright yellow, whereas the Pat McGrath palette has more of a pastel yellow.
There are other differences in the shades, but they are minor- the overall look is one big dupe! Don’t expect poor quality just because the palette is cheap. The shades are all buttery and extremely pigmented!
These colour palettes are exactly how I imagine autumn to look with all the leaves falling from the trees. The colours are natural and earthy-toned with pinks, greens and browns.
If you’re looking for vibrant, alluring, magical, and mysterious and want to stand out from the crowds then you need one of these eyeshadow palettes!
The looks you can create with bronze and greens are endless, but one thing I can guarantee you is that all the looks are beautiful!
Are you seeing what I’m seeing with the Makeup Revolution’s Earth & Stone Focus Palette? It’s a carbon copy of the Pat McGrath Labs Mothership II Eyeshadow Palette!
Not only are the colours all similar tones, but they are also placed in exactly the same layout! Is there such a thing as copyright with makeup?! Hmm, I wonder!
However, I’m not one to complain, a dupe like this is gold! Instead of paying in the hundreds, you can pay under 30 bucks. If that’s not a bargain, what is?! While the general look is exactly the same, there are some subtle differences between the tones of some of the shades.
When it comes to the quality and texture of the palette Pat McGrath has some serious competition.
Pat McGrath is known to make eyeshadow palettes that are top-notch and pretty unbeatable when it comes to quality. Their shadows are buttery, velvety and highly pigmented.
The Pat McGrath Labs Mothership II Eyeshadow Palette comes with 6 pressed shadows with matte, pearl and sparkle finishes. The other 4 eyeshadows are made from hybrid pigmented formulas in metallic, satin sheen, iridescence, and holographic brilliance finishes.
From the packaging and the colours to the application and details, everything about this palette is perfect!
So how does it really compare to the Makeup Revolution Colour Focus Palette – Earth & Stone? That is aside from the identical colour story!
Revolution Pro Colour Focus Palette Earth & Stone comes with 8 shimmers and 2 mattes. Surprisingly (or unsurprisingly for this identical dupe), the quality of these shadows is really impressive!
They are highly pigmented, apply and blend beautifully with barely any fallout. Many say it’s one of Makeup Revolution’s best-ever palettes. This palette is seriously worth every penny!
If you are looking for an even cheaper option than the Revolution Pro Colour Focus Palette Earth & Stone then check out the Wet n Wild Color Icon 32-Pan Eyeshadow Palette. After the Makeup Revolution dupe, I’m sure you have high expectations! I know I do;))
Although the Wet n Wild Color Icon 32-Pan Eyeshadow Palette is not an identical eyeshadow palette, it is still a pretty good dupe! Especially for its price.
It offers the same colours plus loads more, like some blues and more shades of pinks, beiges and greens. The shades are mostly metallic with a few mattes for the neutral colours that you would use for a base or eyeliner, which is very useful to have as mattes.
The pigmentation is good and the blending is easy. Obviously, it’s not as luxurious as the Pat McGrath Labs Mothership II Eyeshadow Palette, and it doesn’t quite live up to the Makeup Revolution palette. Nevertheless, the quality is good and the palette is beautiful!
One negative about the palette is that it doesn’t come with a mirror, however, for the price of the palette you can’t really complain.
It’s a palette well worth the money! This palette is ideal for a first eyeshadow palette, it has loads of colours and they’re all really pretty ones!
Purple is all about royalty and glamour. Mix it with bronze and gold, you’re good to go! You can see on the palettes that none of the purple shades is bright or out there.
Nope, it’s not about being loud, these palettes are all about being classy and elegant. Check out these purple eyeshadow looks for inspo!
I can imagine Kate Middleton using one of these palettes on an official engagement. A natural eye with a bit of colour in the corner to make it deep and give dimension. Perhaps she should give me a call;)
Yes, I’m kidding, I’m sure she has an army of makeup artists who can give me a run for my money!
Anyway, on to the palettes. I’ve put together the 3 best purple nudes’ eyeshadow palettes, they’re all great and suspiciously similar in colour choice.
So the thing with these eyeshadow palette dupes is that they’re all essentially good deals. But…you can always have a better deal!
The Chocolate Bar Palette isn’t costly compared to some of the other shadows we’ve reviewed here. But since it’s the most expensive of the 3 I’ve labelled it expensive.
The swatches are beautiful, I love the chocolate feel that it has, and the purple is a nice touch to it. Because I guess too much chocolate can get boring after a while, said no one ever!
Joking aside, I really do like the purple touch, funnily enough, I wouldn’t put purples with browns but as you see it works really well. So much so, the Chocolate Bar Palette is regularly sold out.
Milani Gilded Nude Hyper Pigmented Eyeshadow Palette is almost a carbon copy of the Too Faced Chocolate Bar Palette. It has one less shade and the shades aren’t all in the same places, but aside from that- wow, what a dupe!
The NYX Professional Makeup Cosmic Metal Shadow Palette is a smaller, even cheaper version of the Chocolate Bar palette and the Milani Nude one. It has 6 shades, all of which are shimmery, whereas both other dupes have more shades and a combination of finishes.
In terms of quality, the NYX palette is good for the price. The shades are easy to apply and blend out easily. Obviously, there are only 6 colours and the palette doesn’t quite feel like a Too Faced eyeshadow palette, but it’s good value for money.
The Milani Nude Palette is a really great eyeshadow palette! The shadows are easy to use, blend beautifully and are highly pigmented with very little fallout. Milani makeup products, in general, are of really impressive quality, and this one is no exception!
Neutral nudes are one of those colour stories that everyone needs a palette of in their makeup collection. Neutral shades are for those times that you’re not sure what to wear, be it a party, a business meeting or even to the park.
You simply can’t go wrong with a good nude palette! I know as a neutral-obsessed junkie I may be a little biased, but surely you agree with me?!
Neutrals are for any and every occasion, you will always feel safe and fit in! My motto is you can never have too many neutrals either! It’s always good to have a spare one for a rainy day:)
The Biba palette is one of the harder palettes to dupe. So I feel lucky I’ve come across some striking swatches from Juvia’s Place and Illamasqua to pit against Natasha Denona.
The Illamasqua Artistry Palette – Elemental is a gorgeous, sultry palette! It has very similar colours to the Natasha Denona Biba Palette with an additional purple shade. Aside from that, the main difference is that the Illamasqua palette only has one shimmer and the Biba palette has 4 shimmery metallic shades.
The formulas of both are equally high-end, and the same goes for Juvia’s Place Eyeshadow Palette. I had actually never heard about this brand before, but it looks like they have some awe-inspiring products!
Their palette’s colour story is actually even more similar to the Biba Palette. The main difference is that the Biba palette has a black shade and Juvia’s Place palette does not.
They’ve arranged the colours a little differently from the Biba palette so it’s not as easy to see it as a dupe. Once you start comparing, you will notice how most of the colours are in fact the same! And may I say for a fraction of the price!
All three of the palettes will give you your money’s worth. They are all highly pigmented, super easy to work and blend with and last throughout the day.
Bronze and Reds
Bronze and red eyeshadow palettes are the perfect party solution! With the deep rich shades and the intense glitters, you will be a head-turner!
Yes, we’ve included another Pat McGrath palette! Their quality and beautiful intense colours are something that so many brands want to copy and get a piece of in their own eyeshadow palettes. Their prices though are the reason why we are duping them!
The Pat McGrath Bronze Seduction palette is one of their most beautiful and dazzling palettes. It’s the most unique yet wearable one, in my opinion.
Although it is more for parties and evenings out. I don’t think I would sport glittery red-eye to work, I’m sure you’ll agree on that one;) It consists of a combination of mattes, shimmers and metallics in deep reds, beautiful bronzes and dark seductive browns.
The quality is typical of Pat McGrath’s perfection, the shades are buttery and velvety, and the shimmers and metallics are intense. The only downside is the obvious- the price!
Thankfully we have some amazing dupes for the Bronze Seduction palette. First up is the MAC Cosmetics Art Library: Flame-Boyant. Just looking at the 2 you can see what an obvious dupe it is.
MAC Cosmetics Art Library: Flame-Boyant has more shades than the Bronze Seduction with the addition of some extra nudes and lighter shades.
While Pat McGrath doesn’t have a matte nude, only a shimmer one, the Art Library: Flame-Boyant does. Which is a nice addition!
The other main difference between the 2 palettes is that the Art Library: Flame-Boyant palette doesn’t have any shimmers, it has a few frost finishes though, which is not so different! Aside from those differences, they are really similar in quality too. MAC Cosmetics makes some good eyeshadow palettes!
Whilst the Art Library: Flame-Boyante is an amazing dupe it is still on the expensive side. If you are looking to save big then Makeup Revolution Forever Flawless Dynamic Dynasty Eyeshadow Palette is your best bet!
Makeup Revolution is known for its good quality makeup that’s super affordable. The quality doesn’t disappoint either. The colours apply easily and they’re easy to blend.
Green is one of those colours that are a little tricky to get right in eyeshadow. If you apply it wrong you can look reeaally bad and when you do it right you can look amazing! You really have to know what you’re doing to pull it off!
Green and gold have always been colours that work well together. Probably because they are right next to each other on the colour wheel. They flow nicely and complement each other perfectly as you can see from the palettes below.
Just looking at the Natasha Denona Gold palette already lures you into wanting it. It has the most gorgeous inviting golds in every finish and tone with a subtle green to it.
This palette was quite a hard one to find a dupe for because it has greens, but they are very subtle. The main colour story is gold.
Melt Smoke Sessions, and W7 24K Gold Rush Pressed Pigment Palette are both really good affordable dupes with a little greener to them. Melt Cosmetics has a few golden shades with one extra green.
As you can expect, the Natasha Denona Gold Palette is really high-end when it comes to quality and colour pay-off. The colours deliver intense pigmentation and they are super easy to blend out.
The same applies to the Melt Cosmetics palette and the Morphe eyeshadow palettes. Yes, you got it, for a fraction of the cost you will get a solid eyeshadow palette that will deliver amazing quality shadows.
The funny thing with these dupes is that the W7 really cheap palette has more similar colours to the Natasha Denona pricey palette than the mid-range palette.
The shades are eerily similar for a fraction of the price. The quality isn’t quite as good as the Natasha Denona palette and the Melt Cosmetics palette, but for the price, it’s well worth it!
Berry Nudes is one of my favourite colour stories ever. Just look at how pretty these palettes are and the looks that be created from them are endless.
From party looks, day looks and office looks anything and everything goes. These palettes are versatile and fun!
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Instant Eyeshadow Palette is one of the most talked-about palettes when it comes to dupes. And I’m in on it too. I love Charlotte Tilbury’s eyeshadows but they are costly.
Too Faced has a very similar palette to their Born This Way The Natural Nudes Eye Shadow Palette. The only difference really is that it lacks options for berry colours. But if we’re talking about swatches, it really nails all the rest. And the layout of the shadows is fun and original!
BYS’ Nude 4 is a really affordable option for the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Instant Eyeshadow Palette. The colours and the layout are exactly the same! It’s almost comical! It was clearly made as a dupe!
All these three want to take you to a Springy, careless Summer picnic. Or even just carry your whole makeup look for normal days. So if you’re going for that, any of these three can be your tea-time friend.
Differences between High-End and Budget Eyeshadow Palettes
As you have seen in this post on the best eyeshadow palette dupes, nearly all expensive eyeshadows have a dupe that costs a fraction of the price. That got me wondering, what is the actual difference in the eyeshadows that some cost in the 3 digits and some in the single ones?
Obviously, there is a designer factor. Are designer brands actually better or are you simply paying for the name?
I decided to dig a little deeper and did a lot of research and the results are interesting at best. There is no guarantee with expensive makeup that it is good quality, and there is no guarantee with cheap makeup. It is all in the individual product.
The reason many expensive brands cost so much is simply that the packaging is expensive to make. If you compare ColourPop packaging to Dior you can see where the money goes instantly. Fancy packaging = expensive product.
Another thing I did hear a lot is that many people with sensitive skin find that cheap brands tend to cause a reaction in their skin more than the more expensive ones.
Quality of pigmentation is also a huge factor in driving the cost of makeup up. Most eyeshadows are made with the same ingredients across the board.
The expensive brands often put more of the good stuff in like pigmentation and the cheaper brands cut corners there. However, this is no rule of thumb. There are plenty of affordable brands that have highly pigmented eyeshadows that last extremely well.
I think it’s all about trial and error and finding the brands that work for you! There are expensive brands that don’t work for me and likewise, there are cheaper ones that do and visa-versa.
Look at The Ordinary and ColourPop– 2 examples of affordable beauty products that seriously deliver!
I hope you have come away from these best eyeshadow dupes with a good dupe for yourself! There are loads of amazing eyeshadows out there, it’s all about finding the right ones.
If you think there are any eyeshadow dupes that should be included in this guide, please drop me a line! You know how I love hearing from you all:)
Hi, I’m Hollie, and I own BeautywithHollie.com. I love everything to do with beauty and love sharing my knowledge, advice, and beauty finds! Makeup and beauty are here to enjoy, and Beauty With Hollie is here to take the stress out of it!
- 15 Easy Winter Makeup Tips for Glowing Skin
- Everything You Need to Know About MAC’s Frosted Frenzy Advent Calendar 2023
- Eye Makeup Tips You Need To Try for Sensitive Eyes
- How To Apply Mascara Like A Pro- The Best Hacks, Tips & Tricks
- 10 Easy Eye Makeup Tips & Techniques For Older Women Over 60
- BareMinerals Complexion Rescue Tinted Moisturizer Review- Find Out The Truth
- The Ultimate Guide to Different Types of Eyeshadows and Their Gorgeous Finishes
- The Different Types Of Foundation In Makeup And How To Choose The One For You
- Contouring for Beginners: A Step-by-Step Guide on How to Contour Like a Pro
Anastasia Beverly Hills bareMinerals Benefit Cosmetics Bobbi Brown CeraVe Chantecaille Charlotte Tilbury Clarins ColourPop Dermalogica Dior e.l.f. Cosmetics ELEMIS Estée Lauder Fenty Beauty First Aid Beauty Fresh Giorgio Armani Hourglass Jane Iredale L'Oreal Lancome La Roche-Posay Laura Mercier LORAC MAC Makeup Revolution Mario Badescu Maybelline Morphe Nars Natasha Denona Neutrogena NYX Origins Peter Thomas Roth Revlon Sigma Beauty Smashbox Stila Tarte Cosmetics The Ordinary Too Faced Urban Decay YSL